| 2/20/07
February 25 is the big night:
names will be written in stone for all time as Academy Award Winners, while
others will become trivia questions and footnotes. Who will win?
Who am I rooting for? Let's find out:
BEST PICTURE
Who's Nominated:
Babel,
The
Departed,
Letters From Iwo Jima,
Little
Miss Sunshine and The Queen
My Preference:
It's a tough call between the powerfully mournful Letters
From Iwo Jima and the spirited, fascinating The
Queen. They're such different movies, but I'll give it to Letters
From Iwo Jima by a nose.
My Prediction:
Man, oh, MAN this is a tough call. Somehow 9 different Critics Circle
honors couldn't get the season's most honored movie, United 93,
onto this list just as Dreamgirls became the first movie
ever to have the most overall Oscar nominations without being nominated
for Best Picture. So what does that leave us with? Babel
won the Golden Globe but not much else. Little Miss Sunshine
is being sold as the Little Movie That Could after Producers' and Screen
Actors' Guild award wins. Letters
From Iwo Jima picked up honors from the National Board of Review and
the Los Angeles and San Diego Film Critics. The Toronto Critics and
the British Academy went with The Queen. The
Departed was the pick of the Broadcast Film Critics Association as
well as the Chicago, Florida, Boston, Las Vegas and Southeastern Film Critics.
In other words, there's no consensus. At moments like this, one must
take a deep breath and focus on what SEEMS like Best Picture. My
pick, with no more than 40% certainty: The
Departed.
BEST DIRECTOR
Who's Nominated:
Alejandro
Gonzalez Inarritu for Babel,
Martin Scorsese
for
The
Departed, Clint Eastwood
for
Letters
From Iwo Jima, Stephen Frears for The
Queen and Paul Greengrass
for United 93
My Preference:
A lot of good work here: Eastwood and Frears brought dimension to
war drama and British palace intrigue I'd never seen before. But
Paul
Greengrass made 9-11 happen
again before my eyes: the skill and importance of his work cannot
be understated, and he's my pick.
My Prediction:
Finally giving Martin Scorsese
his due has been the closest thing this awards season has to a theme.
He's captured the all-important Directors' Guild honor for the first time,
along with the Golden Globe and awards from the National Society of Film
Critics, the Broadcast and Online Film Critics Associations and 13 Critics
Circles. He's lost before as the favorite, but this time seems like
a no-brainer.
BEST ACTOR
Who's Nominated:
Leonardo
DiCaprio for Blood Diamond, Ryan Gosling for Half
Nelson, Peter O'Toole for Venus,
Will Smith
for The Pursuit of Happyness, and
Forest
Whitaker for The Last King of
Scotland
My Preference:
I've complained about the fact that Forest
Whitaker is totally out of
category elsewhere, but his is the best of the three nominated performances
(also Smith and DiCaprio's) I've seen and so I'll stick with him.
My Prediction:
This is one of those categories where the favorite is SO favored, having
won basically everything, that you almost expect an upset, but picking
against Forest Whitaker
is madness. Only a sentimental selection of O'Toole seems remotely
possible as an upset, but the Academy has been down on those kind of choices
lately, particularly since he already has a Life Achievement Award.
BEST ACTRESS
Who's Nominated:
Penelope
Cruz for Volver, Judi Dench for Notes
on a Scandal, Helen Mirren for The Queen,
Meryl
Streep for The Devil Wears Prada and Kate Winslet
for Little Children
My Preference:
When I saw Mirren's awesome work in The Queen,
I never could have imagined rooting for anyone else for Best Actress.
Until I saw Notes on a Scandal.
There's something about Judi Dench's
career-best performance that seems to see into the darkest parts of human
desperation. I've never seen one quite like it, and she'd get my
vote.
My Prediction:
If Whitaker's won basically everything, Mirren's won EVERYTHING.
The only other nominee who can claim a single award of any kind is Steep,
which picked up the Comedy Golden Globe while Mirren was busy winning the
Drama one. It's Helen Mirren
in a rout, particularly because Streep and Dench are previous winners and
if Winslet had this kind of upset in her, she'd have already won.
BEST SUPPORTING ACTOR
Who's Nominated:
Alan
Arkin for Little Miss Sunshine, Jackie Earle Haley
for Little Children, Djimon Hounsou for
Blood
Diamond, Eddie Murphy for Dreamgirls and Mark
Wahlberg for The Departed
My Preference:
Arkin was fine in Little Miss Sunshine, but it was Steve
Carell who gave that movie's most dynamic performance. I'd love to
see Djimon Hounsou win one of these years, but I can't pick on that basis
when I spend so much time complaining about others doing it. The
best of the three nominated performances I've seen was by Mark
Wahlberg.
My Prediction:
It's hard to bet against Eddie Murphy,
who's dominated the second half of the awards season. One favorite
from the first half, The Queen's Michael Sheen,
isn't even nominated. The other, Haley, has lost most of his momentum
in the Murphy landslide, but he's the best bet for an upset.
BEST SUPPORTING ACTRESS
Who's Nominated:
Adriana
Barraza for Babel, Cate Blanchett for
Notes
on a Scandal, Abigail Breslin for Little Miss Sunshine,
Jennifer
Hudson for Dreamgirls and Rinko Kikuchi for Babel
My Preference:
Barraza's the victim of so much silly melodrama in Babel
that I don't really get the widespread praise for her performance.
Breslin's childlike innocence is the key to pulling off Little Miss
Sunshine's surprisingly moving climax. But my two favorite
performances in this category come from Blanchett, who so convincingly
piles characterization and motivation that's nowhere in the dialog onto
her Notes on a Scandal character and
Kikuchi, who wonderfully peels back layer after layer (yeah, I know, insert
nudity joke here) of a character who initially seems utterly unsympathetic.
Given that she does so much of it in the nude and never speaks a word (as
her deaf-mute character only uses sign language), I've gotta give it to
Rinko
Kikuchi for Degree of Difficulty.
My Prediction:
Jennifer
Hudson, the only one of the
five nominees I haven't seen, has owned the awards season up to this point.
She's my prediction, although this category is famously unstable.
Little kids are always a threat, so keep an eye on Breslin. Barraza
is a wild card as well.
BEST ORIGINAL SCREEPLAY
Who's Nominated:
Babel
by Guillermo Arriaga, Letters
from Iwo Jima by Iris Yamashita and Paul Haggis, Little
Miss Sunshine by Michael Arndt, Pan’s
Labyrinth by Guillermo del Toro and The
Queen by Peter Morgan.
My Preference:
Some really good work in here. Little Miss Sunshine's
characters and structure are surprisingly sharp. The
Queen is jam-packed with fascinating information about the nature of
the British government and makes icy real-life leaders into real, believable
characters. Letters From Iwo Jima
takes us heartbreakingly behind enemy lines and gives us a real sense of
how a totally foreign culture fought the Second World War. But of
all these stories, the best is Guillermo
del Toro's masterful parallel
stories about the courage of fantasy and fairy tale characters and real
people in their darkest times. Pan's
Labyrinth isn't in English, so you know full well that no member of
the Academy has actually read the script, but I haven't read any of them,
so that's no reason for me to pick against it.
My Prediction:
Michael
Arndt won the Screen Writers'
Guild award, and I expect him to win here as well. This is the award
most vulnerable to a late-season surge like the one Little Miss Sunshine
has enjoyed. Golden Globe winner Morgan is my best bet for an upset.
While foreign language scripts have been nominated more and more in recent
years, wins are rare: Arriaga has the best shot among the other three
contenders.
BEST ADAPTED SCREENPLAY
Who's Nominated:
Borat:
Cultural Learnings of America for Make Benefit Glorious Nation of Kazakhstan
Screenplay by Sacha Baron Cohen & Anthony Hines &
Peter
Baynham & Dan Mazer Story by Sacha Baron Cohen &
Peter
Baynham & Anthony Hines & Todd Phillips,
Children
of Men by Alfonso Cuarón & Timothy J. Sexton
and David Arata and Mark Fergus & Hawk Ostby,
The
Departed by
William Monahan,
Little Children by
Todd
Field & Tom Perrotta and Notes
on a Scandal by Patrick Marber
My Preference:
I loved both Children of Men and Notes
on a Scandal, but the former's merits are largely cinematic, while
the later, as much as it's buoyed by great performances, is hugely reliant
on its' cracklingly good dialog and well-developed themes. My vote
goes to Patrick Marber.
My Prediction:
Monahan took the Writers' Guild of America prize, but they usually only
get one of the two right and I'm already going with their pick in the other
category. Still, The Departed is the
only Best Picture nominee in this category, and the Academy never picks
movies written by mobs of people, likely eliminating both Borat
and Children of Men. If Cohen had
been nominated for Best Actor, I'd have more of a sense that a Borat
consolation prize might be in the works here, but I sense that its' appeal
lies mostly with younger Academy voters. Enough to get nominated,
but not to win. I'm sticking with William
Monahan.
BEST ANIMATED FEATURE FILM
Who's Nominated:
Cars,
Happy
Feet, Monster House
My Preference:
Three good movies, but my favorite was Monster
House for the way it took me
back to the “old house”-hating spookiness of my childhood. It also
featured the most amazing animation, particularly in the title structure's
climactic rampage.
My Prediction:
Tough, TOUGH call between Cars and Happy
Feet. Honestly, it's kinda a coinflip, but I'm guessing the Academy
will go with director George Miller's live-action track record (he's never
won an Oscar) and Happy Feet's
environmental themes over the more conventional Cars.
BEST FOREIGN LANGUAGE FILM
Who's Nominated:
After
The Wedding (Denmark), Days of Glory (Algeria), The
Lives of Others (Germany), Pan's Labyrinth
(Mexico), Water (Canada).
My Preference:
I've only seen one of these, but I loved it so that I'm confident going
with Pan's Labyrinth.
My Prediction:
It's the first fantasy movie ever nominated in the category, but its' WWII
setting will likely make voters see Pan's
Labyrinth as “important” enough
to merit a win. For an upset, look to The Lives of Others.
And there you have it.
And yes, I will face the music for these picks in a blog entry next Monday.
Until then, enjoy the show, it's the only one we've got! |